Opens in a new tab

Case Studies, Expert Information, Expert Witness, Financial Litigation, Resources

Unicredit v Celestial Aviation

November 22, 2026

This case demonstrates how matters of international concern will take precedence over the rights agreed between private individuals, as well as illustrating the reach of the UK’s financial sanctions.

Background

This case is closely linked to the similar case of UniCredit Bank GmbH, London Branch v Constitution Aircraft Leasing (Ireland) 3 Ltd and another, both of which deal with whether payments under letters of credit were prohibited because of the UK sanctions in place against Russia. The bank believed that they were prohibited from making the payments until the necessary licences had been obtained to allow them to do so, (the ‘Licensing Regime‘).

Letters of credit are a widely used form of security, which oblige the bank to pay the beneficiary on receipt of a valid demand. The security is effective because of the principle of autonomy as letters of credit are seen as wholly independent from other elements in a transaction.

The aircraft leases

This case concerns letters of credit (the ‘Letters of Credit‘) issued in connection with the leasing of aircraft to be used in Russia. Celestial Aviation Services Ltd (‘Celestial‘) provided the aircraft to Russian airlines between 2005 and 2014. Seven Letters of Credit were issued to Celestial by Sberbank Povolzhsky Head Office, a Russian bank, and confirmed by UniCredit Bank GmbH (‘UniCredit‘) which was a German bank acting though its London office.

It is important to note that at the time that the Letters of Credit were issued and the leases entered into, there were no sanctions which prohibited this. The situation only changed in March 2022 when the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 led to the UK extending their sanctions regulations.

Sanctions Regulations

On 1st March 2022, the UK regulations were extended so that the prohibition on financial services or funds relating to military goods and technology, now extended to “critical-industry goods””, including aircraft, which would now be deemed “restricted goods“. The newly imposed regulations prevented anyone in the UK from providing financial services or funds “in connection with an arrangement whose object or effect is… directly or indirectly making restricted goods available… to Russia” (Regulation 28(3)(c) Russia (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019), the ‘Regulations‘.

If there is no struggle, there is no progress.” Frederick Douglass

After this, Celestial terminated the aircraft leases with the Russians and demanded the return of the aircraft, though this was largely ignored, with the Russians continuing to use the aircraft in breach of the agreements.

The Licensing Regime

The Licensing Regime is in place for parties to apply for exemptions to prevent unintended consequences caused by the financial sanctions. A licence from the Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation, a body accountable to Parliament, is a written permission that allows an entity to carry out an activity which would otherwise breach the sanctions. UniCredit successfully applied for and received the necessary licences in 2022 and the principal amounts under the Letters of Credit were then paid.

However, because UniCredit had initially refused to pay, in the belief that Regulation 28(3)(c) prevented them from doing so, a dispute arose around the interest accrued on these amounts up to the licences being obtained, as well as the costs of the proceedings.

Supreme Court decision

The Commercial Court found that the Regulation 28(3)(c) did not relieve UniCredit of its obligation to make payment under the Letters of Credit. However, at the Court of Appeal, this decision was reversed and it was held that the payment obligation was suspended until such time as the relevant licences had been obtained.

Patriotism consists not in waving the flag but striving that our country shall be righteous as well as strong.” James Bryce

The Supreme Court’s decision in March 2026 upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal and interpreted the provisions of Regulation 28(3)(c) broadly. Therefore, these agreements were clearly caught by it, despite challenges to this broad interpretation being raised in the lower courts. It also confirmed that transactions may be caught under Regulation 28(3)(c) even where the underlying contracts did not breach the Regulations when first signed. The same conclusions were reached in the aforementioned case of Constitution Aircraft Leasing.

Meaning of “arrangement”

The aircraft leases were clearly “an arrangement” for the purposes of Regulation 28(3)(c) with the object and effect of making aircraft available to Russian airlines. UniCredit was prohibited under that Regulation from making payments under the Letters of Credit until licences were obtained so interest did not accrue during that period.

It held that Regulation 28(3)(c) is engaged whenever there is a factual link between the payment and the underlying agreement, here an agreement to make aircraft available to Russia. A causal connection is not required, and this broad drafting was intentional to give the Regulations more scope, so covered the Letters of Credit.

The argument that the Letters of Credit represented an independent obligation to the lease was also dismissed, holding that even legally distinct obligations, such as these, will still fall within the restrictions if there is a factual connection with the arrangements caught by the Regulations.

Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act

Section 44 of the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act 2018 (‘SAMLA 2018‘) contains protection for a party whose acts or omissions are done in the reasonable belief that it was necessary in order to comply with the applicable sanctions at the time. In doing so, their actions will not result in civil liability for that act or omission.

A people that values its privileges above its principles soon loses both.” Dwight D. Eisenhower

Even though the comments were obiter, the Supreme Court confirmed that SAMLA 2018 did provide protection to UniCredit against Celestial’s action, whilst it held the reasonable belief that the omission to pay was in compliance with Regulation 28(3)(c).

Commentary

This decision confirms that public policy objectives, such as national security, global relations and complying with international obligations will be prioritised in the application of regulatory sanctions. Sanctions will be interpreted broadly by the courts, emphasising the purpose of the Regulations, which was to put pressure on Russia financially.

This extends to such sanctions superseding private contractual rights between parties, which might otherwise have been enforceable in a civil action. It is arguable, therefore that the decision infringes upon the principle of legal autonomy and the security that letters of credit have traditionally provided.

Going forward, any parties with any form of exposure to Russia should review their existing contracts for potential sanctions issues, as well as expressly addressing such risks in new contracts.

Link: UniCredit Bank GmbH, London Branch v Constitution Aircraft Leasing (Ireland) 3 Ltd and another [2026] UKSC 10 (25 March 2026)

Expert Evidence prides itself on assisting throughout the legal process where required and is a professional firm concentrating on the four main areas of dispute resolution; acting as expert witnesses in financial litigation, mediation, arbitration and adjudication. The firm has a civil, criminal and international practice and has advised in many recent cases. Areas of specialisation include banking, lending, regulation, investment, and tax.

Ask a question about Expert Witness services. We are here to help!

Contact Us Now


Disclaimer: The above case summary is derived from publicly available information and is not intended to be anything more than a statement of the author’s views on the salient factors of the case. It is not intended and should not be understood to be legal advice of any sort. All views are solely those of the author and no use of the summary should be made without statements being checked against the source of information. Expert Evidence Limited takes no responsibility for the views expressed. The copyright of the summary is owned by Expert Evidence Limited but may be used with written permission which may be forthcoming on application through the contact us page. This news item is not intended to imply or suggest that Expert Evidence Limited was involved in the case, only that it is considered an interesting legal development.

You Might Also Like